Round-5 claude-review (merge-ready; all nits):
- 🟡 Added test_empty_doc_types_normalizes_to_null pinning doc_types=[] → None
in record_search_usage metadata (matches the None case).
- 🟡 record_search_usage docstring now notes nc_semantic_search_answer always
meters with doc_types=None (it exposes no doc_types parameter).
- 🟢 BM25HybridSearchAlgorithm.__init__ now sets query_embedding /
query_token_count alongside _embedded_query, so all three cache fields are
instance attributes from construction (was relying on the class-level
SearchAlgorithm defaults).
- 🟢 Ollama embed_batch_with_usage caches _dimension inline (mirrors
OpenAI/Mistral), so the dimension is set via any embed path.
- 🟢 record_indexing_usage documents the independent-record / partial-failure
semantics under SUM aggregation.
Deck #67.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Round-4 claude-review findings (no blockers):
- 🟡 Untested server-layer metering hook (raised across rounds): extracted the
nc_semantic_search embeddings_queries recording into a module-level
record_search_usage() helper (mirroring record_indexing_usage) and added
tests/unit/server/test_semantic_metering.py — value = query token count,
flag-off no-op, None token → 0, doc_types metadata bounding, best-effort
failure swallowed.
- 🟡 Dedup-hit skipped metering invisibly: the existing dedup info log now
states "no embedding/usage recorded" so a "fewer embeddings_queries rows than
expected" audit lands on the dedup path directly.
Deferred 🟢 nits (stated on the PR): search 0-token rows are recorded
deliberately (the query embedding ran; zero is a sum no-op) — documented in the
helper; embed_tokens closure locality and the OpenAI embed() dual path are
unchanged (correct as-is / separate refactor).
Deck #67.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Round-3 claude-review finding:
- 🟡 Double _ensure_bearer() on gateway.embed_batch(). Round 1 made
OpenAIProvider.embed_batch() delegate to embed_batch_with_usage(); because
GatewayProvider overrode both embed_batch() and embed_batch_with_usage() (each
calling _ensure_bearer), gateway.embed_batch() refreshed the bearer twice
(the second a cache-hit no-op). Remove the now-redundant embed_batch()
override: OpenAI's embed_batch() routes through embed_batch_with_usage(),
which the gateway still overrides, so the bearer refreshes exactly once on
every path. The remaining two overrides (embed + embed_batch_with_usage) cover
all four entrypoints; documented the topology.
- 🟢 Added test_gateway_embed_batch_ensures_bearer_once locking in the single
refresh.
Cohere token-fallback (🟢 nit) is already covered by
test_bedrock_with_usage_estimates_when_token_count_absent.
Deck #67.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Round-2 claude-review findings:
- 🟡 Base-class recursion invariant: documented on embed_with_usage /
embed_batch_with_usage that a provider overriding embed()/embed_batch() to
delegate to the *_with_usage variant MUST also override that variant, or the
two recurse. (No recursion today; the shipped providers pair the overrides.)
- 🟡 Processor metering had no unit test: extracted the two-event recording
into a module-level record_indexing_usage() helper and added
tests/unit/test_processor_metering.py (value mapping, flag/zero-chunk no-ops,
best-effort failure swallowed).
- 🟡 SonarQube hotspots (python:S5332) were 3 http:// URLs in the new test
fixtures (mock hosts, never contacted) blocking the quality gate
(new_security_hotspots_reviewed). Switched them to https:// so no hotspot is
raised.
- 🟢 Zero-chunk guard: record_indexing_usage() no-ops when chunk_count == 0, so
an empty document no longer writes zero-value billing rows.
Deferred (stated on the PR): Mistral x.index-or-0 sort key (pre-existing,
equivalent), CHANGELOG note for the Ollama /api/embed switch (CHANGELOG is
commitizen-generated from commit bodies, which document it), class-var
query_token_count (safe under the per-request instance pattern).
Deck #67.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Round-1 claude-review findings:
- 🔴 Multi-doc_type search billed N embedding calls as 1. nc_semantic_search
loops search() once per doc_type on one BM25HybridSearchAlgorithm instance,
and each call re-embedded the query, so only the last query_token_count was
recorded. Cache the dense embedding per query on the (per-request) instance
so the query is embedded — and metered — exactly once regardless of how many
doc_types are searched. This also removes the redundant per-type embed work
and avoids billing a user N× for one logical query.
- 🟡 Ollama embed() now delegates to embed_with_usage() so single and batch
embeds use the same /api/embed endpoint (was the legacy /api/embeddings),
keeping _detect_dimension and other embed() callers consistent.
- 🟢 round() instead of truncating int() when coercing provider-reported token
counts (forward-compatible if a provider ever returns a float).
Tests: per-instance query-embedding cache (embedded once across 3 doc_types;
re-embeds on a different query).
Deferred (stated on the PR): mistral/openai single-embed dual path (changes
tested error/request semantics on the cloud-critical path — separate refactor),
bedrock boto3 sync-in-async (pre-existing; no new invoke_model calls per doc).
Deck #67.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
embeddings_queries now records the embedding request's token count (the unit
upstream providers bill on) instead of an operation count, and fires on the
indexing path too. Previously only semantic search recorded it (value=1), so a
re-indexing run produced no embeddings_queries events at all — only pages_chunks.
- Provider layer: additive embed_with_usage / embed_batch_with_usage surface the
per-request token count (Mistral/OpenAI usage.total_tokens, Bedrock Titan
inputTextTokenCount, Ollama prompt_eval_count); a char-based estimate is the
fallback (Simple, and any provider/response without a token field). Gateway and
EmbeddingService forward through. The count travels as a return value / a
per-request SearchAlgorithm attribute — never on the singleton — so concurrent
indexing + search can't mis-attribute bills.
- Indexing (vector/processor.py): records embeddings_queries (value=batch tokens)
alongside the existing pages_chunks event.
- Search (server/semantic.py): value is now the query embedding's token count,
relayed from BM25HybridSearchAlgorithm via query_token_count.
The astrolabe_embeddings_queries Stripe meter (sum aggregation) now sums tokens
with no CP/Terraform change. The meter "queries"->tokens naming/unit
clarification (homelab-terraform #254) + CP rollup/portal copy is a follow-up.
Deck #67.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Simplify the OCS status guard to `if status and status != "ok"` — falsy
(missing/None/"") is tolerated more naturally than the explicit tuple.
- Add `test_value_error_from_ocs_failure_returns_none`, covering the
OCS-failure ValueError flowing through `_get_enabled_apps_or_none` to the
scan-all fallback.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Correct the misleading `test_malformed_envelope_returns_empty_set`
docstring: an empty-set return does NOT trigger the
`_get_enabled_apps_or_none` scan-all fallback (which fires only on
exceptions); optional apps are gated off for that cycle, Files unaffected.
- Check OCS `meta.status` in `get_enabled_apps`: a 200 carrying
`status != "ok"` now raises, so a 200-with-failure envelope routes through
the scanner's scan-all fallback instead of silently gating every app off.
Add a test for the failure-status raise.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Extract `_app_enabled` to a module-level helper so the gate predicate is
unit-tested directly instead of via an inline copy that could drift.
- Move `import logging` to module scope in test_scanner_app_gating.py.
- Harden `get_enabled_apps` OCS-envelope parsing (`X or {}` / `or []`) so a
present-but-null `ocs`/`data` coerces to empty instead of raising on
`None.get`; add parametrized malformed-envelope tests.
- Use https:// in the test request URL (SonarCloud S5332 hotspot).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The vector-sync scanner polled every indexed app (Notes, Files, News,
Deck) for every provisioned user on each scan cycle. When a user lacks
an app, its REST API returns 404; these were caught (indexing
continued) but flooded tenant logs with repeated 404s, scaling with
users x disabled-apps x scan-frequency and masking real failures.
Add NextcloudClient.get_enabled_apps(), which reads the per-user
/ocs/v2.php/core/navigation/apps endpoint (respects group
restrictions). Chosen over /cloud/capabilities because the News app
advertises no capability and never appears there.
scan_user_documents now resolves the enabled-app set once per cycle and
skips the Notes/News/Deck scans for apps the user lacks. Files stays
unconditional (core Tags API, not a 404 source). Detection failures
fall back to scanning every app (prior behaviour), so a transient
nav-endpoint blip never silently halts indexing; the per-app 404 guards
remain as the safety net.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Assert the open card stays visible under status="open" in the
deck_get_stack integration test (completes the partition check).
- Move the _append_archived_cards docstring closing quotes to their own line.
deck_get_stack's status="archived" + include_cards=False path is left as-is:
a single get_stack call is the cheapest way to obtain the stack metadata
there — routing it through the archived fast-path would fetch every archived
stack on the board just to strip the cards, which is heavier, not lighter.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- deck_get_stack: fetch active + archived concurrently for status="all", and
for status="archived" source the stack from /stacks/archived in a single
call (skip the active fetch whose open cards are filtered out anyway),
matching deck_get_cards' pattern.
- Type the `client` param of _archived_cards_by_stack as NextcloudClient.
- Extend the stacks/overview integration test to assert status="archived"
(only the archived card) in addition to status="all".
- Document the third_party/astrolabe submodule mount policy in CLAUDE.md:
unmounted by default (CI installs the published app-store version); mount
only for tightly-coupled feature work needing CI integration, then revert.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The active Deck listing endpoints (StackService::findAll /
CardMapper::findAllForStacks and StackService::find / CardMapper::findAll)
filter out archived cards at the SQL level — only the /stacks/archived
endpoint returns them. The client-side status="all"/"archived" filters in
deck_get_cards, deck_get_stacks, deck_get_stack and deck_get_board_overview
therefore operated on a list the server had already stripped of archived
cards, so they could never surface one. deck_get_card (by ID) bypasses the
filter, which is why it appeared to work. Fixes#842.
When status is "all" or "archived", also fetch /stacks/archived
(client.deck.get_archived_stacks) and merge those cards back in per stack —
concurrently with the active fetch where applicable. status="open"/"done"
are unchanged and cost no extra call.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- semantic.py: normalize both None and [] doc_types to null in the
metadata so a future `metadata->'doc_types' IS NULL` query counts the
all-types case consistently.
- test: use a fixed past date in test_occurred_at_roundtrip instead of a
future literal (deterministic, no "why this date" confusion).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Non-blocking follow-ups from the merge-ready review:
- semantic.py: bound the doc_types copied into embeddings_queries metadata
to _USAGE_METADATA_MAX_DOC_TYPES (16). doc_types is caller-supplied with
no max_length on the tool signature; capping the stored copy keeps one
JSONB row from ballooning (not a billing/injection risk — CP ignores
metadata, binds are parameterized).
- migration: note that `metric` is intentionally unconstrained Text and
that adding a third metric requires keeping the CP-side catalog in sync,
else the rollup silently ignores the new rows.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- hooks: document why user_id in metadata is safe — it stays tenant-local
(the CP rollup aggregates GROUP BY (day, metric) into usage_daily, which
has no metadata column, so it never reaches Stripe) and is retained to
keep Deck #67's future per-user attribution derivable from the app DB.
- migration: instantiate the SQLite-side column types (sa.Text() etc.) for
visual parity with the instantiated Postgres types.
- tests: assert the WARNING contract in the unserializable-metadata test
too; add an autouse fixture that resets UsageEventStore._shared_instance
so a stray shared() call can't leak across tests.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- store: guard UsageEventStore.shared() with a class-level anyio.Lock so
two concurrent cold-start callers don't both build (and one silently
overwrite) the cached instance — mirrors get_shared_storage(). Document
that tests should construct the store directly to avoid singleton leak.
- migration: rename 20260610 -> 20260607 and fix Create Date to today so
`alembic history` isn't future-dated (revision id 007 / down_revision
006 unchanged; single head verified).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- remove accidentally-committed .claude/scheduled_tasks.lock (Claude Code
runtime artifact swept in by `git add -A`) and gitignore it; the rest
of .claude/ stays tracked.
- store: cache UsageEventStore.shared() as a process-wide instance so the
hot search path doesn't allocate a fresh wrapper per metered query (the
wrapper is stateless beyond its storage handle).
- hooks: pass enabled=True directly (the outer guard already confirmed
the flag) instead of re-reading settings.usage_metering_enabled.
- migration: document the no-TTL retention design (control-plane rollup
owns the lifecycle; the data plane only appends).
- tests: assert the best-effort error path logs at WARNING (observability
contract).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- store: add optional `enabled` param to record_usage_event so hot-path
callers (nc_semantic_search) pass the already-resolved flag instead of
forcing a second uncached Settings build (ADR-024); falls back to
get_settings() when None so the store stays self-gating for standalone
use.
- hooks: thread enabled= through both call sites; bump the outer
shared()/construction failure log from debug → warning so "metering
enabled but no billing data" is visible at the default INFO level.
- migration: instantiate postgresql.JSONB() to match the sibling
TIMESTAMP(timezone=True) column.
- tests: fix the misleading "asyncpg returns JSONB as a JSON string"
comment; add occurred_at dialect round-trip test and an enabled-param
short-circuit test.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Deck #67 data-plane slice: tenant Pods record billable operations
(embedding queries, pages/chunks embedded) into an app-DB usage_events
table that the control plane later pulls read-only into the billing
ledger and syncs to Stripe Meter Events.
- migration 007: usage_events table (Postgres TIMESTAMPTZ/JSONB/UUID
with portable SQLite fallbacks), indexed (occurred_at, metric) for the
CP rollup's per-day range scan + GROUP BY metric.
- UsageEventStore: best-effort, flag-gated writer reusing the shared
RefreshTokenStorage engine; ON CONFLICT (event_id) DO NOTHING for
idempotent retries; dialect-branched occurred_at bind. All work
(incl. metadata JSON encode) is swallowed so a metering failure never
surfaces to the user op.
- USAGE_METERING_ENABLED flag (default off) wired through Settings +
env map; off-path touches no storage, so OSS self-hosters get an empty
table and zero write overhead.
- two recording hooks: embeddings_queries (per nc_semantic_search, which
nc_semantic_search_answer reuses) and pages_chunks (after dense
embedding succeeds, covering both in-process and procrastinate paths).
- storage.acquire()/.dialect public seams so the sibling store doesn't
reach into the underscored internal.
- tests parametrized over SQLite + Postgres: flag-off no-op, roundtrip,
ON CONFLICT dedup, JSON/NULL metadata, and the best-effort swallow of
both DB errors and unserializable metadata.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Address claude-review round 5 on PR #868: add
test_all_blank_pages_returns_empty_list documenting that PageAwareChunker
returns [] when every page is blank — and asserting parity with
DocumentChunker, which already returns [] for whitespace-only non-empty
content. The empty-chunk-list case is therefore pre-existing pipeline
behavior, not new to this PR.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Address claude-review round 4 on PR #868: tighten the assign_page_numbers
guard from `page_boundaries is not None` to a truthy check, so a PDF with an
empty boundary list no longer enters the trace span and fires the alarming
"NO page numbers assigned" warning for a harmless no-op.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Address claude-review round 3 on PR #868: add module-level
`pytestmark = pytest.mark.unit` so TestPageAwareChunker and
TestDocumentChunkerPositions are collected under `-m unit`, matching
test_processor_routing.py.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Address claude-review round 2 on PR #868:
- Extract the use_page_aware branching into a pure `should_use_page_aware`
helper and cover the (doc_type, page_boundaries, page_aware_setting) matrix
in tests/unit/test_processor_routing.py (file+boundaries+enabled, empty
list, None, non-file doc types, disabled setting).
- Clarify the PageAwareChunker.chunk_text no-boundaries comment: the processor
pre-filters via should_use_page_aware, so that branch is a direct-call safety
net, not a production indexing path.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Address claude-review round 1 on PR #868:
- use_page_aware now gates on `bool(page_boundaries)` instead of
`is not None`, so a PDF that yields an empty boundary list takes the
char-based path explicitly (assign_page_numbers no-ops on []) rather than
the page-aware chunker's no-boundaries fallback. Same result, clearer intent.
- add test_oversized_page_with_leading_whitespace_offsets, exercising the
start+start_index offset path for an oversized page whose sub-chunks have
leading whitespace.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
DOCUMENT_CHUNK_SIZE/OVERLAP were documented as "words" with a 512/50
default; the implementation measures characters and defaults to 2048/200
(config.py, DocumentChunker). Update docs/configuration.md (config block,
tuning guidance, examples, env-var table) and env.sample accordingly, and
cross-reference DOCUMENT_CHUNK_PAGE_AWARE for the PDF path.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add PageAwareChunker, which splits paginated documents (PDFs) on page
boundaries first and only character-splits pages larger than chunk_size.
No chunk spans a page boundary, so page_number is always exact and stored
excerpts never lead with a neighbouring page's text. When chunk_size is at
least the largest page, this yields exactly one chunk per page: a
predictable vector count (== page count), a flat per-page embedding cost,
and zero cross-page overlap duplication.
Gated by DOCUMENT_CHUNK_PAGE_AWARE (default true). When false, the legacy
char-based DocumentChunker + post-hoc assign_page_numbers path runs
unchanged. Only doc_type="file" with page_boundaries (PDFs) takes the
page-aware path; notes/deck/news are unaffected.
Measured on a 15-page record (query "leadership award louis", target =
top-half of page 15): char-based degraded the target to dense-rank 10 at
cs=2048 (OCR) and mislabeled its page; page-aware restored rank 1 across
every fusion/modality and chunk size, with correct page labels and clean
snippets.
BREAKING CHANGE: PDFs are re-chunked page-aware by default. Existing
deployments will re-index PDF content on the next vector sync (different
chunk counts and page_number labels). Set DOCUMENT_CHUNK_PAGE_AWARE=false
to retain the previous char-based behaviour.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Tagging an existing file/folder emits only OCP\SystemTag\MapperEvent — never a
Node*Event — so tagged PDFs were previously only picked up by the hourly
scanner. Subscribe to the tag event and reconcile membership so adding/removing
the `vector-index` tag (re)indexes in near-real time.
- webhook_presets: add OCP\SystemTag\MapperEvent to the files_sync preset
(NC 32+, where MapperEvent gained getWebhookSerializable(); harmless on older
servers — it just never fires).
- webhook_parser: parse MapperEvent (objectType=files) into a path-less file
"reconcile" task. The payload carries only a fileid + tagIds (no name/path),
so assign and unassign both collapse to a reconcile.
- processor._reconcile_tag_event: resolve the fileid against the user's current
vector-index PDFs (find_files_by_tag). Present -> index with the resolved
path/etag; absent -> flip to delete. Naturally handles "an unrelated tag
changed" and a tagged folder's own fileid (no-op; the scanner still expands
folders to descendants).
- Unit tests for the parser branch and the reconcile.
The matching admin-UI preset change ships separately in the astrolabe app repo.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Address PR #863 round 4: classify_from_text's docstring now states that the
image_heavy flag (and the image-coverage trigger) are only set when
image_coverage is supplied, so the flag reads zero for tenants with
DOCUMENT_OCR_DETECT_SCANNED=false -- self-documenting the metric semantics.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Address PR #863 round 3:
- classify_from_text emits the "scanned" flag (was "no_text_layer") for the
empty-text-layer case -- same name + meaning as classify_pdf, so
astrolabe_document_classifier_flag_total isn't split across two labels for the
same concept (and matches the metric's documented vocab).
- classify_from_text logs at DEBUG when image_coverage length != the expected
min(pages, MAX_SAMPLED_PAGES), so a 1:1-alignment contract break (extractor
reorders/skips pages) surfaces instead of silently misattributing coverage.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Address PR #863 round 2:
- classify_pdf now flags a page needs_ocr on the SAME three signals as
classify_from_text (image scan OR low text-quality OR near-empty), not image
coverage alone. Previously a word-merged digital doc with no images routed
"fast" via classify_pdf but "ocr" via the pipeline -- so an operator
reproducing routing offline got a different answer. They now match.
- Add a test that when image_coverage is shorter than the page boundaries (the
MAX_SAMPLED_PAGES cap on large scans), the leading page uses the scan signal
and later pages fall back to text-quality.
Left as-is: overlong_score (>20) partially overlaps merge_score (>12) -- the
double-penalty on very-long tokens is intentional, not a bug (per review).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
